That Pretty Place Bed & Breakfast

212 US 20 , Middlebury, IN 46540 USA (Show map)


The heart of Amish Country is the home of That Pretty Place, a Shipshewana, Indiana area bed & breakfast inn. We invite you to come and unwind at our B&B located in the small, friendly, rural town of Middlebury, IN, in the northern region of the state. Experience peaceful lodging in the seclusion of our quiet, country setting. Enjoy our spacious 37-acre grounds, with walking trails and meadow along the old Pumpkin Vine Railroad, and through the woods. Our pond is stocked and ready for your fishing pole. Our bed and breakfast, with nine guest rooms, five of which are honeymoon suites is perfectly sized for small group events and intimate romantic getaways! We cater to couples on a romantic getaway as well as to corporate retreats, spiritual retreats, church retreats, golf retreat groups, and scrapbooking and quilting weekends..



Write A Review
  • Guest room4.5
  • Service5
  • Value4.8
  • Cleanliness4.8
  • Onsite Dining4.8

BNB virgin

5 on July 07, 2012

Had never stayed at a bnb. It will be hard to stay at a chain hotel again without being over critical. Without experience to compare, I am very impressed with this place. It is secluded without being isolated. I will keep it in mind for future mini get aways.

Boyfriend's Birthday Weekend

5 on April 11, 2012

Me and my boyfriend was on a road trip when I found this bed and breakfast on the internet. When we arrived we were greeted and everything was wonderful. It was quiet and beautiful. I was expecting a continental breakfast but we had a hot meal. What a surprise! I love this place and before we left we talked of coming back the followong month. Thanks for making this experience so GREAT!!!!!

Hidden Treasure

4.6 on January 24, 2012

What a wonderful treasure! That Pretty Place Bed & Breakfast is tucked away back in the woods in beautiful Middleburry, IN. They have two different lodges, the main lodge has your basic simple rooms with one Honeymoon Suite. Each room has its own private bath and small TV. The Honeymoon Suite has its own bath plus an amazing two person jacuzzi tub. The common room in the main lodge has a fridge stocked with soda and water. There is also a fireplace, however it was not working during our stay. We stayed in the Honeymoon Suite in the main lodge and truly enjoyed it. The dining area was simple but nice. It was a bit chilly, we were there in the winter and the dining room is difficult to heat. The innkeepers were fantastic and prepared a great breakfast each morning. We had stuffed French toast one morning and biscuits and gravy the other. The innkeepers truly cared about their guests and did everything that they could to make your stay enjoyable, however they were not constantly talking your ear off. The other lodge on the property is very new and very modern. It has suites instead of rooms. It is absolutely gorgeous, and had the whole lodge not been booked by an entire family for Christmas we would have stayed there. One of the things that sets That Pretty Place apart from other bed & breakfasts is their grounds. They have a pond and lots of trails to walk. It is truly beautiful and so relaxing to just stroll through the woods. I would highly recommend this Bed & Breakfast to anyone looking for a nice place to stay for an unbeatable price. In my opinion it is one of the BEST bed & breakfasts in northern Indiana.

Anniversary Getaway

4.4 on June 20, 2010

The breakfast was very very good!! The room is nice, and was very clean. The jetted tub was very relaxing. The location is very quite and peaceful. Deb and Dave are wonderful hosts.

View More Reviews



South Bend, IN (SBN-Michiana Regional) 33 miles

Directions to property:

That Pretty Place Bed and Breakfast Inn is located in the small town of Middlebury, Indiana. If you are searching for a hotel in the Shipshewana area of Northern Indiana, our rural B&B is a peaceful and cozy alternative to the typical hotel stay. We offer convenient Amish Country lodging just minutes from Elkhart and Goshen, IN, and we are approximately an hour’s drive from Notre Dame University. •From the Indiana Toll Road, I-80/90, Exit at interchange number 107. •Go south on State Road 13 (which becomes Main Street) about three miles to Middlebury. •Continue south on SR 13 through town to the intersection of US 20. •Go west on US 20 1/2 mile. •That Pretty Place is on the north side of the road, watch for the sign... •Follow the signs down the long, winding lane through the woods to our Inn... •Our street address is: 212 U.S 20, Middlebury, IN 46540

Area Attractions

Antique Shopping, Gourmet/Fine Dining, Nature area, Shipshewana Flea Market, Hudson Auto Museum, Amish Country Cooking Restaurants, Religious Services

Inn Details

On-site amenities

Fireplace, Library, Telephone, Wedding Facilities

Room amenities

Air conditioning, Alarm clock, Coffee/Tea facilities, Desk, Hot tub/whirlpool tub, Microwave, Satellite/Cable TV, TV, Wi-Fi

Visit Website


  • Open All Year Round: Yes
  • Smoking Allowed: Outside only
  • Drinking Allowed: No
  • Alcohol Provided No
  • Suitable For Children: Limited Children allowed if whole facility is rented by one party.
  • Childcare Provided: No
  • Guest Pets Allowed: No
  • Disabled Access Yes

Terms and Conditions

  • Accepted payments Other



Ryan & Crystal Miller

Languages spoken


Resident Pets

Visit Website




  • Serving Location: Breakfast/dining area