Voted "Best in the Midwest" in Midwest Living Magazine and and "Best Breakfast" in Inn Traveler Magazine. Experience the elegance of a turn of the century Queen Anne home at the Reynolds House Bed and Breakfast in beautiful historic downtown Sturgeon Bay. The Reynolds House has natural oak woodwork and paneling, leaded glass windows throughout with an oak fireplace. Period antique furnishings fill the many common gathering rooms and guest bedrooms. Each bedroom has a private bath, some with whirlpool tubs; ceiling fans, cable television and air conditioning.
5 on April 20, 2015
Our stay here couldn't have been better the room was lovely and the breakfasts were amazing. David, our host, made us feel at home and had great suggestions on what to do and where to eat in the area. We will definitely be going back to Reynolds House our next trip to the area.
5 on February 25, 2015
The owner David showed us a great weekend, the service was great, the food was top notch and David made our stay very comfortable. We gained a new friend over the weekend and we plan on returning real soon.
5 on February 21, 2015
David was a great host. I arrived late evening and David accommodated with hot tea and some fine home made night snacks. Some great history in the house. Rooms/beds were very comfortable. I stayed in the Cortland Room. Great multi-course breakfast got me off the next morning. A one night stay.
4.8 on February 15, 2015
David created an excellent environment of cuisine and conversation. More twenty-somethings should consider the bed and breakfast experience! Wonderful.
5 on February 12, 2015
It was a pleasure to stay at David's house. Not only was he an excellent house but his breakfasts were over the top. Proportions were just right, not to big and not to small. He was very accommodating and simply put a sweet inn keeper. That's for your hospitality Dave
5 on November 28, 2014
I would recommend staying at this B&B because it was nice and quiet, David was very pleasant, his stories were very interesting, and his dog was a lot of fun to play with. The bed was the most comfortable bed I have ever slept on, and the pillows were just as comfortable. The location was perfect because it was close to everything we wanted to do. We will definitely be visiting here again!
4.8 on October 24, 2014
The house is an amazing combination of Victorian and Arts & Crafts architecture, with lots of interesting history and a variety of room features. It is very clean and well kept, and the owner has a background in period architecture and conservancy that really make the home come alive. The owner, David, is a wonderful host and cook. He accommodated my wife's unusual diet with tasty modifications to his recipes. All in all, a very pleasant stay and we will be back!
5 on October 22, 2014
My wife needed a weekend away. It took me a while to discover something suitable and available in nearly all of Door County, but I happened upon an available room at the Reynolds House. I had not expected to get the entire upper/attic floor, but there it was, and so when we arrived, it was a wonderful surprise. A very private 3-room space includes a private bath with a shower and a separate jacuzzi tub, a living room with a TV and couches and chairs, and a lovely bedroom with a large bed and all the peaceful amenities one could ask for. The new owner of the Reynolds House is about the nicest proprietor one could wish for. He was full of suggestions about where to go (and which towns to avoid because of high traffic), what to see and which restaurants offered the best fish, the best deals, and so on. His breakfasts were unique and delicious, and we both had a weekend to remember. Would we do it all again? Oh yeah..
4.4 on October 18, 2014
Our stay at Reynolds House was a gift for our anniversary. It was our first stay in Sturgeon Bay and staying at the Reynolds House made it very special. We had the entire 3rd floor, which is designed to be occupied only by one couple. This B&B is quiet, comfortable, quaint and run by David... a very gracious host! He has a little dog, Celie, who is very good with all of his guests. Some may not think that a B&B should have a dog present, but she literally NEVER barked and made our stay even more enjoyable! David is a great chef with stories to share from his many travels. He has not been in Door County for very long, but he has educated himself very quickly about the history and was very good about helping us to plan our day time-wise by being aware of what was available around us and details about services and practices of various attractions. All in all, we loved our stay at Reynolds House and would highly recommend it! P.S. You will NOT find any hotel with bedding as comfortable as what we slept on at this B&B... I guarantee it!!
4.8 on October 15, 2014
My wife and I recently stayed at the Reynolds House to celebrate our 25th Wedding Anniversary. David Hayes was an amazing host! He helped us figure out what to explore in Door County. Also, he puts his heart into creating unique breakfast experiences. The food was delicious and he kept us entertained with stories of food , the Reynolds Family (who had been the original owners) and some of his many adventures. The B&B was nicely appointed with antiques and gave you a real sense that you had stepped back in time to a more quiet and restful place. We definitely intend to come back! Jim and Anne Marie
Door County, Fish Creek, Egg Harbor, Bailey's Harbor, Sister Bay, Ephraim, City, Downtown, Small town, Wine country
Green Bay, WI (GRB-Austin Strauble Field) 45 miles
Antique Shopping, Art Galleries, Beach, Gourmet/Fine Dining, Historical interests, Lake, Movie Theater, Museum, National/State parks, Nature area, Performing Theater, Picnic area, Religious Services, Vineyard, Winery
Private Home Bed and Breakfast, Bed and Breakfast
Board games, Computer, Fax Machine, Library, Piano, Telephone, Videos
Air conditioning, Alarm clock, Amenities Basket, Ceiling fans, DVD Player, Fireplace, Hot tub/whirlpool tub, Radio, Satellite/Cable TV, TV, VCR
Bicycle rental, Bicycle riding trails, Bicycles, Bird watching, Boating, Canoeing, Cross-country ski trails, Fishing, Golfing, Hiking trails, Horseback riding, Hunting, Kayaking, Sailing, Shopping, Sight-seeing, Ski rentals, Snow shoe trails, Swimming, Swimming pool, Water sports