Listed below are 42 B&Bs near Shelter Island, New York. If you know of any other B&B in this area, please let us know!

B&Bs near Shelter Island

 Sort by: 
Lumber Lane Bed and Breakfast - Bridgehampton, NY The Classic Hamptons Experience: Style, Service and Comfort. Harborwoods Guesthouse - Sag Harbor, NY A well-appointed bed and breakfast located just south of Main Street. Built in 2006. All... Mill House Inn - East Hampton, NY Spectacular dog & child-friendly boutique hotel & “the best breakfast ever” in historic... Mainstay Bed and Breakfast - Southampton, NY Mainstay, a charming 1870's restored colonial guest house, in the lovely Historic Village... Copper Beech Inn - Ivoryton, CT SELECTED BY CONNECTICUT MAGAZINE AS "CONNECTICUT'S BEST COUNTRY INN" FOR THREE CONSECUTIVE... Angels' Watch Inn B&B - Westbrook, CT A charming Connecticut Bed and Breakfast where all guest rooms have fireplaces, private... Shorecrest Bed and Breakfast - Southold, NY Enjoy great food, luxurious beds and old world comfort in this Victorian Mansion by the sea. A Butler's Manor - Southampton, NY A White-Glove Welcome to the Hamptons Ruby's Cove Bed and Breakfast - Greenport, NY Free Bicycles, Gourmet Breakfast all in the heart of historic Greenport The Grandfield Bed&Breakfast - Madison, CT Beautiful 3.5 acre property 1/4 mile from Hammonasset State Park Olde Country Inn - Shelter Island, NY This charming Victorian inn, originally built circa 1886, is located on beautiful Shelter... By The Bluff Bed and Breakfast - East Marion, NY BeachSide. Finest Master Suite on the North Fork. Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast and Spa - East Marion, NY Romantic B&B -Spa Services, Award winning Gourmet Breakfasts, Jacuzzis, Fireplaces, near... Sag Harbor Loft and Studio Guest Bedroom - Sag Harbor, NY Sag Harbor Upstairs Loft with Optional Guest Bedroom on Private Landscaped Retreat Harvest Inn Bed & Breakfast - Peconic, NY The Harvest Inn is all about the local food and wine. Join us for a Wine Country escape... Aunt Dot's Victorian Bed and Breakfast - East Marion, NY This beautiful Victorian Home was built in 1860. It has two front porches for your sitting... The Huntting Inn - East Hampton, NY The Huntting Inn is one of the most beautiful and historic landmarks in the oceanfront village... Bartlett House Inn - Greenport, NY The Barlett House was built at the turn of the century by John Bartlett, NY State Assemblyman.... The Farm Bed and Breakfast - Riverhead, NY We are a working horse farm offering Western riding lessons on well-trained reliable horses. Vintage Bed & Breakfast - Cutchogue, NY Walk to Long Island's award winning Wineries, antique shops, farm stands or magnificent... The Scranton Seahorse Inn - Madison, CT Luxuriously appointed accommodations along with the charm and ambience of a historic homestead. Quintessentials Bed & Breakfast and Spa - East Marion, NY New York Times "Best B&B" Full-Service Spa & Romantic Rooms. Minutes to Area Beaches, Wineries.... 3 Liberty Green Bed & Breakfast c.1734 - Clinton, CT Historic Shoreline B&B; walk to beach, shops, restaurants; Each rm w/ 2 person jacuzzi! Orient Inn - Orient, NY Come and discover this beautifully restored 1906 Dutch Colonial/Arts and Crafts style Bed... Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast - Greenport, NY Built around 1870, Harbor Knoll is a gracious water front country home. Built in the Dutch... Stirling House - Greenport, NY Breathtaking waterviews and the "walkability factor" make Stirling House the premiere B&B... Westbrook Inn B&B - Westbrook, CT Step Back In Time To An Era Where Life is Simple & Romance is in the Air... At this charming,... The Morning Glory Bed and Breakfast - Greenport, NY Experience quaint seaside living with a relaxing stay at The Morning Glory B&B in Greenport,... Bee and Thistle Inn - Old Lyme, CT This 1756 inn is nestled on five acres bordering the Lieutenant River in the township of... Andrew's Legacy - Cutchogue, NY This fourth generation family home is within walking distance of 6 wineries, beaches and... Deacon Timothy Pratt Bed & Breakfast - Old Saybrook, CT Historic shoreline town, walk to everything! Elegant rms w/ fireplaces, jacuzzis, canopy... Boxfarm - Southampton, NY A friendly warm staff, exceptional service, the best breakfasts in the Hamptons. Come stay... ShinnEstate Farm House - Mattituck, NY Welcome to Shinn Estate Farmhouse, your home on the vineyard. From sunrise to sunset relax... Captain Stannard Bed and Breakfast Country Inn - Westbrook, CT An Inn for all seasons, this historic Georgian style B&B exudes a casual, country elegance. Blue Iris Bed and Breakfast - Cutchogue, NY Jerry and Lorry Siani welcome you to their newly constructed farm house style Bed and Breakfast.Three... Acorn Hollow B&B - Southold, NY A destination unto itself in the heart of L.I. Wine Country catering to your every comfort. Sannino Vineyard Tuscan Suite - Cutchogue, NY On a Vineyard in North Fork Wine Country The Griswold Inn - Essex, CT The Griswold Inn, established in 1776, is the oldest continuously operating inn in the country! Tidewater Inn - Madison, CT The Inn offers an inviting and elegant atmosphere of antiques and estate furniture, while... East Hampton Village Bed & Breakfast - East Hampton, NY Lovely, turn-of-the-century Village bed and breakfast filled with warmth, antiquity and... Home Port Bed & Breakfast - Peconic, NY Victorian B&B in the heart of Wine Country, near beaches and tasting rooms, antiques and... Inn at Harbor Hill Marina - Niantic, CT We've done it again! Awarded 2009-2010 "Best of New England" by BedandBreakfast

Shelter Island Nearby Cities

For more bed and breakfast inns near Shelter Island, New York, check the cities listed below. Also noted is the approximate distance from Shelter Island, New York.

Shelter Island Heights B&B's - 1 milesOld Saybrook B&B's - 16 miles
Greenport B&B's - 3 milesWestbrook B&B's - 16 miles
East Marion B&B's - 4 milesOld Lyme B&B's - 17 miles
Southold B&B's - 5 milesClinton B&B's - 18 miles
Orient B&B's - 5 milesNiantic B&B's - 19 miles
Sag Harbor B&B's - 5 milesMadison B&B's - 20 miles
Peconic B&B's - 7 milesRiverhead B&B's - 20 miles
Cutchogue B&B's - 9 milesEssex B&B's - 20 miles
Bridgehampton B&B's - 9 milesEast Quogue B&B's - 20 miles
East Hampton B&B's - 11 milesDeep River B&B's - 22 miles
Mattituck B&B's - 12 milesWesthampton Beach B&B's - 23 miles
Southampton B&B's - 13 milesGuilford B&B's - 23 miles

Find an Inn Start Search Over

Check availability:

Guests:
 Rooms:
Check-in:
 Check-out:

or call
800-GO-B-AND-B
to book by phone
Expand Your Search

Nearby States:

1. Connecticut B&B's
2. Massachusetts B&B's
3. New Hampshire B&B's
4. New Jersey B&B's
5. Ohio B&B's
6. Pennsylvania B&B's
7. Rhode Island B&B's
8. Vermont B&B's
Featured Review Review a B&B
Rating:
This was our first time at a bed and breakfast.
Submit a review, and you could win a $1000 BedandBreakfast.com Gift Card!

Shelter Island

Find the perfect Shelter Island New York Bed and Breakfasts and Inns. Stay at a B&B for the unique lodging alternative to large hotels!

Tools

  • Print page
  • Email to a friend
Click to verify BBB accreditation and to see a BBB report.HACKER SAFE certified sites prevent over 99.9% of hacker crime.

Featured Property

Bed and Breakfast
Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast and Spa
(East Marion, NY)
  19 reviews
Click here to reserve online with the Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast and Spa
Romantic B&B -Spa Services, Award winning Aromatherapy Baths, Jacuzzis, Fireplaces, near Greenport

Gift Cards

Click here for information on B&B Travel Gift Cards and Certificates - the perfect gift for holidays, birthdays, weddings, anniversaries, retirements, Mother's day, Valentine's day and Christmas!
Order Online Now!
or call 800-GO-B-AND-B
Print all Participating B&Bs
in Shelter Island
B&Bs that welcome gift cards are marked with this icon:


Top Destinations

  1. Manhattan
  2. Boston
  3. Cape May
  4. San Francisco
  5. Newport
  6. Napa
  7. Charleston
  8. Key West
  9. Savannah
  10. Santa Barbara
  11. Asheville
  12. Austin
  13. Carmel
  14. Brooklyn
  15. Philadelphia
  16. Chicago
  17. New Orleans
  18. Galena
  19. Saint Augustine
  20. San Diego
  21. New Hope
  22. Provincetown
  23. Los Angeles
  24. Seattle
  25. Spring Lake