4.0 on September 27, 2015
What a find! The lodge is beautiful, tastefully decorated, immaculately clean. The breakfasts are wonderful, tasty, huge and delicious. The hosts have impeccable taste and are present but not obtrusive, welcoming and completely genuine.
4.2 on November 06, 2012
For two years in a row we have come to Starlight Lodge to pick up our kids from sleep away camp. Our times there have been some of our best family memories. Jerry's Breakfasts! Especially what we call Jerry Bacon which we now try to make at home--it is thick-cut, baked, bacony perfection. The inn is sparkling clean, tastefully appointed, quiet and secluded. Jerry is a wonderful host and my kids (twins 10 and older son 12) are very fond of Jerry and really look forward to winding down for a few days there after the wildness of camp. My husband and I feel very welcome and yet he gives you plenty of privacy. For our family it really has begun to feel like a home away from home. Thank you Jerry...
5 on October 14, 2012
My husband and I have made this our home away from home. It is a wonderful place to get away and out of the city to enjoy each other, ride our ATV's on the O&W trail and take in the wonderful peace and quite. David and Jerry are very warm and friendly and their breakfast is absolutely wonderful.
5 on June 09, 2011
We stayed at Starlight Lodge at the end of May. The innkeepers were very professional and welcoming. The lodge was beautifully decorated and well maintained. The grounds beautiful. Our room perfect. Beakfast nice and custo to our needs. I fished the East Delaware and the Beaverkill while my wife made herself at home in the lodge. What a great place to leave a fishing widow! Many thanks to Jerry and David and plan on seeing us again next year.
5 on February 13, 2011
From the moment we entered we felt very welcome by our friendly and very accomodating host, Jerry. The lodge is eloquently decorated with antiques and various paintings and pictures, very pleasing to the eye! The room we stayed in was #10. Everything was very clean especially the bathroom. We were made to feel very much at home. The fireplace area is especially warm and inviting (the couch and chairs are very comfortable). The breakfast was very delicious, especially the bacon, which would invite you from your room just by the smell throughout the lodge. We would highly recommend this B&B based not only on the beautiful area but also because the local Starlight Inn has an outstanding dinner menu and the service staff was excellent! Overall, this is the best B&B we've ever stayed in and we already booked an extended weekend in July for our anniversary (can't wait to see the area with no snow on the ground, leaves on the trees and water on the lake) Thank You Jerry for a memorable weekend, Dale and Sue
5 on September 12, 2010
Jay and David were the best. we stayed in the Lodge due to overcowding at my friends place on Lake Hiawatha. the breakfast was something worth going to bed early for. Every little nook in the place had intersting books and mountain life memorabilia. A reduced rate was presented to us for the 3rd night of stay without asking. Jay was a wealth of knowledge of the area as he is a local for many years. Planning on returning in the fall for foliage run with bird-watcher friends. Starlight Lodge is well worth the $$. highly recommended.