Reviews

Score Breakdown based on 49 Reviews

4.6 out of 5
 
  • Guest room  5
  • Services  5
  • Value  5
  • Cleanliness  5
  • Dining  5

Explanation of Our Ratings

  Outstanding
  Exceeded my expectations
  Met my expectations
  Okay, but below average
  Unsatisfactory

Ideal experience

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Our most favorite get away!

About the reviewer

  • Between 26-35 years old

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

A breath of fresh air in the country...

About the reviewer

  • 55+ years old

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Tranquil woodlands heaven!

About the reviewer

  • Between 36-45 years old

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Awesome Stay!

About the reviewer

  • Between 26-35 years old

  • First time staying at a B&B

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

One of my favorites!

About the reviewer

  • Between 36-45 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Excellent romantic weekend!

About the reviewer

  • Between 26-35 years old

  • First time staying at a B&B

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Great fall stay

About the reviewer

  • 55+ years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

A wonderful experience

About the reviewer

  • Between 36-45 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

HIghly recommended

About the reviewer

  • Between 26-35 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for an event

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Wedding weekend in Accord New York

About the reviewer

  • 55+ years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling for an event

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Captain Schoonmaker's B&B was just what we needed!

About the reviewer

  • 55+ years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

The Music of Water

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Lovely 18th century Inn, in beautiful surroundings

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Frequently stays at B&Bs

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Captain Schoonmakers : Croce

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Excellent Experience

About the reviewer

  • Between 26-35 years old

  • First time staying at a B&B

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

By the waterfall

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

unexpectedly terrific

About the reviewer

  • 55+ years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Review from New Paltz guest

About the reviewer

  • 55+ years old

  • Frequently stays at B&Bs

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Rest and relaxation

About the reviewer

  • Between 36-45 years old

  • First time staying at a B&B

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Sound of running water, the taste of breakfast

About the reviewer

  • 55+ years old

  • Frequently stays at B&Bs

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling on business

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

cute and quaint bed and breakfast

About the reviewer

  • Between 26-35 years old

  • Frequently stays at B&Bs

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

best weekend EVER !!!!

About the reviewer

  • Between 36-45 years old

  • First time staying at a B&B

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling to visit family

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Lovely Weekend

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Love the Captain!

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Felt like home

About the reviewer

  • 55+ years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for an event

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Just What I Was Looking For

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Almost never stays at B&Bs

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Home Away from Home

About the reviewer

  • Between 36-45 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

A Perfect stay

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Almost never stays at B&Bs

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for an event

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Excellent Stay

About the reviewer

  • Between 36-45 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Lasting memory for romantic & relaxing stay

About the reviewer

  • 55+ years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Relax and renew!

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Frequently stays at B&Bs

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

My Third Home

About the reviewer

  • 55+ years old

  • Frequently stays at B&Bs

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Absolutely Charming

About the reviewer

  • 55+ years old

  • Frequently stays at B&Bs

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

A Little Piece of Heaven!

About the reviewer

  • Between 36-45 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Wonderful place for a 3-day getaway!

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

The coziest B&B we've ever stayed in!

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Wonderful Surprise

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Autumn Vacation

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • First time staying at a B&B

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Comfortable & Quaint

About the reviewer

  • Between 18-25 years old

  • First time staying at a B&B

  • Typically stays in budget lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Great place

About the reviewer

  • Between 36-45 years old

  • Almost never stays at B&Bs

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

A Warm Welcome in High Falls

About the reviewer

  • 55+ years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Just what we were looking for!

About the reviewer

  • Between 26-35 years old

  • First time staying at a B&B

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

A Great Stay

About the reviewer

  • Between 26-35 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Still the Best B&B in New York State!

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs twice a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

A Must-Stay for Honeymooners!

About the reviewer

  • Between 36-45 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling on vacation

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Wonderful!

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

A Perfect Early Spring Getaway

About the reviewer

  • Between 18-25 years old

  • Frequently stays at B&Bs

  • Typically stays in premium lodging

  • Was travelling for a weekend getaway

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Wonderful stay!

About the reviewer

  • Between 45-55 years old

  • Stays at B&Bs once a year

  • Typically stays in moderate lodging

  • Was travelling to visit family

  • Overall 
  • Guest Rooms 
  • Service 
  • Value 
  • Cleanliness 
  • Dining 

Quick Snap Shot


Explore Captain Schoonmakers

Check Availability Visit Website
  • Address 913 Route 213
    High Falls, NY 12440
    USA
  • Phone+1-845-687-7946
  • EmailContact Innkeeper