It's great to see interesting historic properties renovated into B&Bs and Amsterdam Castle provides a rich experience. The Officer's Wing is nicely laid out with the main bedroom within a round turret. And breakfast in the Kennedy Room evokes... read more

When I was a child, the romantic lure of the castle had me climbing its walls and running on its grass. This past week I was able to return to my birthplace as an adult, and take a walk down memory lane. How exciting it was to see that not only was... read more

Amsterdam Castle is the most unique B & B I have stayed in. I stayed again on the way home from Boston. Very inexpensive and lovely. There is a restaurant in Amsterdam(walk there) that is amazing. It is Italian, and has been there 30 yrs. I had... read more

How crazy that there is such a castle in America! I enjoyed the military history of the building. They just don't build them like they used to. Clearly the family has done a thoughtful and attractive renovation. I liked using the wifi while... read more

I visited from Germany and really liked the castle! I Played basketball in the gym, enjoyed the nearby bicycle path and relaxed on the lawn in front of the castle.

View Reviewer Info

Plenty of room to spread out in "our wing". We enjoyed the history and the beautiful restorations The Phemister's have achieved. Wonderful breakfast brought to our suite.

View Reviewer Info

This castle is so authentic. The good hosts are the innkeepers. Warm and friendly reception. Spacious rooms, just what you need for a nice stay.

We loved our overnight stay at Amsterdam Castle. Very unique, and as bicyclists, it was within minutes of a paved, level bicycling path that runs along the canal. The inn was close to a restaurant that had great food and drink. Staying here was... read more

It was an experience to remember. I visited several castles in Germany and I always hoped I would one day have an opportunity to spend a night in a castle. This weekend I came very close. It didn't feel like I was in a bed and breakfast home but a... read more

I have family in the area and have always had a problem finding a nice place to stay so I am thrilled to have found such a great gem. What started out as a family trip turned into a great getaway due to European feel of the place. The rooms were... read more

I'm actually an Amsterdam local that was looking for something different to celebrate an anniversary with my girlfriend... and what a great choice this ended up being! All I can say is EUROPE... I live 1/2 of the year in Southern Italy and have... read more

who expects to stay in a castle in upstate new york? but there it was right in amsterdam, looming above us as we arrived. I loved the European feel and the Nutella they served with warm croissants. And the claw foot tub was a great touch.... read more

“We visited from Manhattan and loved it. It is just 3 hours from NYC the city and it is such a beautiful place. We really enjoyed having a glass of wine on the front moat. It is like Europe in upstate New York. The charming owners speak French and... read more

It is quite something to be shown one's private wing in the castle. The rooms are all decorated in style with the building and contain loads of interesting furniture and decoration details. The Kennedy room is amazing, makes you want to throw a huge... read more