Andrews Inn Reviews


View details

  • Guest room4.6
  • Service4.8
  • Value4.6
  • Cleanliness4.8
  • Dining4.3

Score Breakdown based on
42 Reviews

Write A Review

Great Again

5 on January 13, 2015

Our third visit to Key West. The last two we stayed at Andrews Inn. We'll definitely be back again whenever we're in the Keys. We consider it to be "our place".

What a great little place!!

5 on December 10, 2014

My experience at Andrews Inn was outstanding. I had the pleasure of staying at the Tree Top Studio (a warm, intimate, complete unit) and I don't believe I could have chosen a better place for my mini vacation at Key West. The staff was extremely polite and helpful. They accommodated parking for me during my stay (something that's a luxury in Key West), and I was about 30 steps away from Duval Street - the center of Key West. As they say: location, location, location! Thank you for your service and I look forward to doing it again.

The perfect Key West getaway spot.

4.6 on December 06, 2014

This was our first trip to Key West, and we planned it rather on the fly, so we didn't know exactly where to look for places to stay. We happened across the Andrews Inn's website and the description sounded exactly like what we were looking for. The great location in the middle of old Key West made it easy to walk to all of the sights, restaurants, bars, and beaches that we wanted to see. And when our feet were too tired, the available bikes to rent made it even easier to get around. Not to mention the friendly and attentive staff helped us greatly in planning everything we wanted to do during our oh-too-short stay on the Key. If (when) we go back to Key West, we'll be sure to check in with Andrews Inn first.

Super cute

4.4 on November 20, 2014

Stayed in Paris room. Small but very clean & cute! Great Happy Hours. Perfect location! Would definitely return & try the other rooms!

Andrews Inn Key West Fl

5 on November 10, 2014

We really enjoyed our stay at Andrews Inn. Everyone was super friendly and the place was beautiful. It's bordered by the Hemingway house which is really neat. Also, it's really close to Duval St without being situated right on top of it. I would definitely stay hear again!

Mango Hideaway!

5 on October 30, 2014

What a great place! Andrews Inn is THE spot in Key West! We will be back. The Mango Hideaway was perfect for our anniversary! Don't rent a car, just walk or bike! Christina and Lisa are the best! They will book outings for whatever you want to do. You won't be disappointed, book now! Thanks to the whole staff! Jay and Stacy - Green Bay, WI

Off the fast track!

5 on October 13, 2014

Although we were mere steps from Duval Street, our stay at Andrews Inn was quiet, quaint and relaxing. We had everything we needed while there (even snorkle equipment!!!) and enjoyed the morning breakfast, the afternoon happy hour and of course the friendly staff. If you want to feel at home while being conveniently located don't look any further. And, you will also have friendly felines and colorful cock-a-doodle doos to keep you from missing your left behind pets! We will definitely stay here again if returning to Key West. Thank you for a memorable four days. The Horbalys, Cville VA

Andrews Inn

5 on September 16, 2014

As a first time visitor to Key West I looked at B&B locations ; The Andrews Inn was exactly what I was looking for. From the quaint cottage atmosphere , the top notch staff , and the proximity to all Key West has to offer I couldn't have made a better choice.

Great little place next to Duval

4.6 on September 13, 2014

Stayed here with my wife for 3 nights this september. Andrews Inn offers small, but nice rooms on a great location: Duval is around the corner and our room overlooked the garden of the Hemingway house. Staff was very friendly and polite: they helped us with parking and booked our trip to Dry Tortugas for us. The contintal breakfast was ok and is served on the terrace. The daily free happy hour is also nice.

Getaway Hideaway

4.2 on September 10, 2014

Great experience. Can't wait to go back for a longer stay

Pleasantly surprised

5 on September 05, 2014

Walking thru an alley to get here was a little suspect but once we saw our quaint room, that was clean and roomy we were surprised and pleased. Surprised again at the selection of the breakfast that's included. Keep in mind this is not your modern hotel and you will see roosters walking around, which is no different from anywhere else in the Keys. Go in with an open mind and you will be pleasantly surprised

Outstanding accommodations in Key West

4.6 on August 05, 2014

The moment that my wife and i arrived at the Andrews Inn, we fell in love with the place. Our host, Lisa, was the absolute best. She showed us to our room and made certain that everything was perfect during our stay. We were in town of Hemingway Days, and the balcony of our room overlooked Hemingway's Whitehead Street home. What a thrill to stay in the shadow of such a legend. Ask for the "Pamploma". Our room was not large, but average sized by Key West standards, but was immaculate. It came with a refrigerator which actually worked, and worked well, and the AC kept the room quite comfortable, something you really want in Key West in July. There is a small pool on the property, nested away under tropical vegetation...the perfect spot to rest up for a night on Duval Street. They put out a good continental breakfast each morning, and a great happy hour is put out at 5PM each day. This is our second time staying at Andrews Inn, but it will not be our last.I am entering a dining score here only because I have to to save this review. To my knowledge Andrews Inn does not have a restaurant, but I will rate them as "Exceeded my expectations" based upon the continental breakfast and happy hour.

Cute, quiet, and great location

3.4 on July 28, 2014

We stayed in the Roma room. It was very cute, comfortable, and clean. The location is perfect - steps off Duval, but not loud or noisy. The pool is a nice feature, even though we didn't get to use it in our short stay. I would definitely recommend.

Can't wait to go back!

5 on July 05, 2014

Andrews Inn was awesome. It was my first stay at a bed & breakfast and it surpassed my expectations. I would recommend Andrews Inn to my friends and can't wait to return myself.

My new go-to for Key West

4.2 on June 30, 2014

Loved the cottage rooms, felt like my home away from home with updated and perfect keys decor. Pool is smaller than I expected but nice to sit around and take a dip. Bike rentals on property were super convenient and we definitely took advantage of this service. Friendly service. Yummy breakfast by the pool. I would have loved to try the mini quiches, waffles or french toast that I read on the website but this Sat and Sun they did not have these items - hopefully next time! Still, breakfast was fresh and appreciated and it was nice to have Mimosa's!!


4.6 on June 19, 2014

Absolutely wonderful stayng at this bed and breakfast! The staff is wonderful and the breakfast and happy hour are great!

Perfect to Stay While in Key West

4.8 on June 09, 2014

My husband and I could not have been more pleased with the Andrews Inn. It is in a perfect location and close to everything... While it's just steps from Duvall, you don't hear the noise or see the traffic on Duvall. For the most part, it's within walking distance to most anywhere you could want to go. Get scooters if you really want to see the island. As for the Inn itself, we stayed in one of the rooms that was directly off the pool... It was perfect... The bathroom was spacious, clean and updated. And the room was nice, modern beachy and clean. There was enough room for two people to not feel cramped. The small personal deck right outside the door was perfect. Breakfast every morning was great! The Happy Hour every evening was the perfect way to cap off the day, get ready for dinner and get to know other guests. The staff was gracious and helpful... They truly wanted our Key West stay to be unforgettable and perfect, which it was. Whether you are in Key West for a low-key vacation or are looking for a more lively experience, Andrews Inn is Absolutely Perfect!!

Charming Bed & Breakfast

4.4 on February 20, 2013

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at Andrews. The staff and owner, Tom, were extremely accommodating and friendly. It is very near all the action, yet in a quite setting. We would definitely stay there again.

Andrews Inn, Key West FL

4.6 on December 05, 2011

My wife and I went to celebrate her 50th birthday and found paradise in a BandB. The staff was absolutely on task and smiled every step of the way, the rooms were clean and comfortable, the mood was light, and the feeling was more like being at a family home than a B and B. The location is perfect for everything in KW and Jorge or Tom are always willing to share thier knowledge of the Island to help visitors along the way. We'll be back and that about says everything!

An Amazing Stay

5 on October 21, 2011

I can not begin to express how much we enjoyed Andrews Inn!! We stayed for a week for our Honeymoon. The room was full of chacter, clean and a very comfortable bed. The canopy of trees, our private front porch, pool, poolside breakfast, happy hour and most of all Jorge, made for a wonderful stay. Key West is an amazing island in itself but Andrews Inn's great location and staff/ownership made it even more enjoyable and stress free. We will be returning as soon as possible.

Great location, service, and atmosphere

4.8 on June 03, 2011

Room was small but clean and nicely decorated. Staff warm and helpful. Great happy hour and standard continental breakfast. Excellent poolside area that is quiet. Great location central to Duval St. Would definitely recommend!

Andrews Inn, Key West

5 on May 06, 2011

Just spent four great days in one of the pet friendly cottages. It was everything we hoped for. Tom and Nancy, and their staff (especially George and his little buddy Sebastian), could not have been more accommodating. We felt totally at home, as did our golden doodle, Yogi. We are already planning our return visit. Ralph & Marianne

Quiet Oasis in Key West

4.6 on April 01, 2011

Our 2nd time back to Andrews Inn. Quiet, relaxing, nice breakfast by the pool. Jorge & Tom know all about Key West and are happy to make reservations or suggestions. Happy Hour daily allowed us to meet all the guests. We have already reserved our stay for 2012. I would not go anywhere else in Key West.Clost to town & beach but far away from the Duval craziness. A wonderful vacation.

Our Stay at The Andrews Inn

5 on September 20, 2010

We stayed at The Andrews Inn for one week and it was great. Owners and staff are exceptionally helpful and courteous. Great location , in the middle of a block, only a short walk ( eight or nine ) blocks from mallory square and the heart of old town. Its like finding a private oasis in the middle of Key West. The continental breakfast , which includes champagne, and the free happy hour each afternoon are especially nice touches. We stayed in the Madrid apartment and the only suggestion we have is to add a small table or bench to the bathroom to hold your toiletries, a very minor item. Thanks, we certainly plan on coming back. Rex & Karen

The place to stay in the heart of Key West!

4.8 on June 10, 2010

We stayed at Andrews Inn the first of June. The rooms were very nice, the service exceptional and this made our visit great. Andrews Inn is about a half block off Duval Street (the main street) and you cannot hear any traffic noise even while outside. This is a little oasis in the middle of town. You are close enough to bring packages back to your room anytime or just rest. I would highly recommend the Inn. The staff is SO pleasant. Go and enjoy.

Home Away From Home

4.4 on April 15, 2010

My husband and I have been going to Key West for eight years now and have already booked our stay for next year. We have stayed with Andrews Inn everytime and would not stay any where else. The staff there are awesome and will do anything to make your trip one of the best you ever had. The cottage we stay in has everything that you would need, from TV, CD player, toaster, blender, internet, irons, pot, pans, dishes, you name it anything you would need away form home. I can't say enough GREAT things about this jewel of a place to stay!!!! I you stay with them and enjoy!

Great Find

4.8 on April 05, 2010

Wonderful experience. We came in weary from a long drive to Key West, and were made to feel right at home immediately by the friendly staff. After a week - we did not want to leave. The manager - Jorge - is very knowledgeable about activities and can call and set nearly anything up for you (dinner recommendations, boat tours, kayaking, etc.). Happy hour and breakfast around the pool is a nice touch – it lets you meet people from all around in a friendly atmosphere. Location is great – next to Duval - but amazingly private and secluded feel. Stayed in Paris room – nice vaulted ceilings and remodeled bathroom. Key West is great with so much to do, but our accommodations at The Andrew’s Inn made the trip special.

A perfect place in Key West

4.0 on January 30, 2010

The small Inn is just steps away from Duval but there was no noise or hustle from the street. The staff was very helpful, knowledgeable, friendly and just plain happy! It was a great stay and the Inn is a great value. When we come back we'll call them first!! Pa couple

Andrews Inn - always fantastic

4.8 on November 04, 2009

We have stayed here many years and it is always fantastic, over-the-top, yet quaint and you feel like you are coming home for a visit. Close to Duvall to walk everywhere, but secluded too.

Awesome !

4.6 on November 03, 2009

Just returned from Fantasy Fest and hated to leave Key West & Andrews Inn. Couldn't find a complain here if I tried....convient location, clean and friendly... Staff was awesome; Jorge was superb!..David from Boston


5 on October 19, 2009

We stayed at Andrews for four days. It was one of the best inn experiences ever. The staff is so friendly, helpful, and kind. The rooms were beautiful, quiet and very very charming. They offered a happy hour and a very nice breakfast. I can't say enough kind words about Andrews Inn.

Stay once and you'll be back again & again!

4.2 on October 14, 2009

We wouldn't think of trying anywhere else in Key West, were lucky to have stayed here on our first visit. We went for our honeymoon and now think it wouldn't be anniversary without being at the Andrews Inn, where we feel like family. Great hosts and staff. Best travel value around.

just awesome

4.6 on August 18, 2009

This place is so close(by close I mean down a driveway) to all the great night life Key West has to offer, without being on a loud, busy street. Tom and Jorge were great at suggesting the perfect places to eat. The breakfast each morning was just what we needed...we sat next to the pool, planning our day. We will certainly be back!

A hidden paradise on Duval

5 on June 23, 2009

This was our 4th stay at Andrews Inn--which is just steps off all the action of Duval but still quiet and relaxing. Very charming and the staff goes out of their way to see that you have everything you need. Afternoon cocktails are included--a great way to get started--then off to great food and music just walking distance away. Virgilios is great for music and dancing--just a few blocks up off Applerouth. We would not think of staying anywhere else--you must try their private charter boat for snorkeling with Alma--such a unique experience.

An intimate oasis in paradise!

5 on June 23, 2009

We were entranced by the beautiful and well designed courtyard of Andrews Inn. The staff is very friendly and every effort is made to make their guests stay comfortable and memorable. Although the room was small, the ambiance and attention to detail made this a wonderful place to stay. We will return and highly recommend it!

Hello George and Blanche

4.0 on June 03, 2009

What a great experience! beautiful rooms, gorgeous view; great people to great you. We will be back

Our Week in Paradise

4.4 on May 24, 2009

We have stayed at the Treetop Studio for the last six years and it has become our home-away-from-home (at least for one week out of the year). The private second-floor balcony is very inviting, a great way to start the day over a leisurely breakfast in a lovely tropical setting. The outdoor Jacuzzi is a real treat after a day of shopping and biking and a great way to end the day relaxing under the stars. Even though the apartment is within walking distance of all the Duval Street attractions, biking is the best way to get around the rest of the island. We bike to the beaches, parks, grocery stores and Garrison Bight, where we go fishing on Captain John’s Greyhound and bring the catch back for a late afternoon fish fry. When we rent our bikes from the Andrew’s Inn, the bikes and keys are waiting for us in the apartment when we arrive. The Treetop is ideal for us but what really makes our vacation perfect is the staff. Jorge, Blanch and Martin are the most accommodating, friendliest and helpful staff you will meet anywhere. Jorge always handles all of our arrangements to perfection in a very professional manner. However, it is his easy laugh and outgoing personality that really sets him apart. Everyone assists you in any way they can, usually going well beyond what is expected. On our last trip I off-handily mentioned to Blanch how beautiful the bougainvillea vine was he was trimming and he said he would send a bouquet over with Martin. Martin, our housekeeper, and his dog Fluffy, the sweetest scooter-riding dog on the island, delivered an absolutely beautiful large vase of flowers to our room. What a wonderful surprise when we came back! This is just one example that portrays how special the Andrew’s Inn staff makes their guests feel, there are many others too numerous to mention.

Andrews Inn was very Relaxing

4.0 on March 26, 2009

My husband and I had a very relaxing time at Andrews Inn Everyone was very helpful and friendly Breakfast and Happy hour were great We are already planning our next return and hope to bring our friends

Same Time Next Year!

4.2 on March 25, 2009

We love this hidden treasure. We have met wonderful new friends and are already booked for 2010. You won't find hosts like Tom, Jorge & Nancy anyplace. Excellent breakfast and cocktails in a beautiful setting!

a little bit of heaven

4.8 on June 25, 2008

The Andrews Inn was a little bit of heaven. While there, we felt so at home. It was just perfect. The complimentary breakfast was outstanding and we loved the touch of the complimentary cocktail hour. I am ready to go back right now!!! Jackie, Joan, Lauretta and June

Hidden Jewel

4.6 on June 20, 2008

My husband and I just got back home last week after spending 6 nights at Andrews Inn. We LOVED it and can't wait to go back. It's location was perfect, the staff so friendly and helpful, the room was meticulously clean. We also particulary loved that Andrews Inn is a green lodging member. The happy hour is a wonderful time to socialize around the pool. Breakfast is very simple but Jorge's Honey Mango/Strawberry Butter is delicious! Our room was small but the bed was comfortable. We 100% recommend Andrews Inn.

I'll be back

4.4 on February 09, 2008

Very pleasant environment. within walking distance to most things and still a quiet retreat from the noise and heat of Key West. Nice accomodations, extremely pleasant surroundings, friendly and helpful hosts. I'd recommend highly to all. They treat you the way you want to be treated on a vacation! Like a ROCK STAR:-)

Andrews Inn


  • Nightly Rate $145 - $379
  • Reviews (42) 4.6
  • Rooms 10

Contact Innkeeper

  • Phone +1-888-263-7393
  • Fax 1-3052940021
  • Toll free 1-8882637393