Cornelius Daly Inn

What a disappointment that such a beautiful home had every little detail thought of except the most important thing -- the demeanor of the innkeepers. The reserve on our arrival was disappointing; but the overt coldness the next morning (particularly by the wife/breakfast chef) was something my husband and I had never encountered in a B&B. So, all in all, I would caution inn seekers to consider why they select one B&B over another. Yes, for us, the ambiance is always critical; but the nature of the inn keepers will make or break the experience. In this case, the experience was not just broken -- it was shattered -- by the unwelcoming attitude on the part of the owners, which during breakfast, extended to everyone at the otherwise elegant dining room table. So, would we recommend this B&B? Unequivocally not. What a shame.

Our room was about what we expected, nice and clean. Everything was a bit creaky, which should be expected in a home this old. The breakfast really stood out. It was absolutely delicious and filling. I would return for the breakfast alone.

Nice place to stay. A little noisy from traffic. Not much in eureka.

Hotel was nice although Eureka had a run down feel about it. Probably least enjoyable stay on our road trip.

Everything was very nice. My coworkers and I had a long work day before arriving and called to let the innkeeper know we were showing up late. He made arrangements for us to get our keys. Very easy to work with and a very nice stay.

Rooms and furnishings were exceptional! Very clean an polished. Traffic noise from all directions a bit loud, but that's what you get in the city I guess. Lingering cooking smells were noticeable upon entry but got used to them. Gardens were very lovely too. I could picture a small wedding or other reception taking place there. Good neighborhood bistro located near by too with excellent food. Nice change from the chain hotels we've been staying at in southern CA and Napa area.

We've stayed at the Cornelius Daly Inn a number of times over the past 3 years. The owners Donna & Bob Gafford are most hospitable, and Donna serves delicious breakfasts. We've never had the same breakfast twice over the past 3 years. The Victorian Rose Suite is beautiful and comfortable. The entire house has been restored to its historical period. Don't miss the Christmas ballroom on the 3rd floor. As long as we have reason to visit Eureka, California, we will return to the Cornelius Daly Inn.

The Cornelius Daly Inn is a wonderful victorian home, lovingly restored with a polished finesse. excellent hosts, and the institution of sit down breakfast being served at 8:30 in the morning allows you to meet other guests on their way through Eureka. Loved The wine and cheese served in the afternoon. it is easy to reach the redwood tall tree grove from this place. Highly recommanded. Helmut & Brigitte, Vienna Austria

Breakfast was great and the company enjoyable. The woodwork and design of the Daly Inn is preserved beautifully and was much appreciated.

We love this b&b. Country setting. Clean. Gourmet food prepared by the host. And very reasonable.

Breakfast was delicious, and they specially prepared our meals as per our dietary restrictions (one of us is vegetarian and one of us has Celiac disease and cannot consume gluten). The service was friendly and wonderful!

Breakfast was remarkably delicious. Non-intrusive but very helpful hosts, close to beautiful outdoor activities, would stay there again in a heartbeat.

Helpful host. Superb breakfasts. Well located. We thoroughly enjoyed our three nights here!

Bob was extremely friendly and we greatly appreciate his hospitality. We would certainly come back and stay at the inn if we're in Eureka again. Thank you.

A very comfortable, quiet, and interesting stay. The host was very hospitable but did not intrude. Breakfast was outstanding. The room was large, beautifully furnished, and comfortable. The house itself was architecturally fascinating. Lovely garden. Clay Frederick, Australia

The Cornelius Daly Inn is a beautifully and authentically furnished home that is close to the downtown Eureka restaurants and shops. The street is mostly quiet with some light traffic noise at the typical morning rush hour time (we were out and about in the evening). The staff was attentive and considerate and very helpful with information on places to see. We went to see the Wedding Rock at Patrick's Point State Park - a wonderful excursion that we would have missed without the help from our hosts. They also gave us great tips on restaurants and served wonderful breakfasts as well. Highly recommended. Mike & Deb from SCV

We enjoyed our two night stay at this lovely. old fashioned inn. The innkeepers were gracious and helpfull and we are so looking forward to returning in August when we attend our son's wedding in their beautiful garden.

Bob was great and the hospitality was wonderful. We had the cheese souffle and it was wonderful!

the rooms are beautiful and bristling with antiques. of course the place is clean -- jeez! our mattress (in The Guest Room) was extremely firm, if you like that sort of thing. Bob was oddly grumpy -- hopefully he was just having a bad day. breakfast service, mostly by Donna, was far more pleasant and the food was good. we got a good deal on a very elegant room.

We were driving up the coast of California and we decided to stay overnight in Eureka. We spotted a quaint Victorian called Daly Inn and stopped to see if they could accommodate us – without a reservation. The Garden Suite was available and after seeing it we took it immediately. After some wine and pleasant talk we went to our room. We were met by a well decorated three room suite overlooking the garden. How quaint: a room’s name that really means something. The suite had every amenity that one would like to find in a B & B. The next morning, during a marvelous breakfast, prepared by hostess Donna Gafford and served by co-owner Bob Gafford, we discussed the availability of things to do locally. After hearing about the guided wine tour, we opted for an additional day’s stay so we could visit three local wineries. The trip was to an appellation that we’d never heard of before – Willow Creek. It is situated in The Trinity Alps. The appellation was established in 1947 but has remained untouched by the hoards. The trip was well worth the time and cost. At each winery, we were met by the owner/winemaker. Donna had packed a great lunch for us and the winemaker and his wife, which we enjoyed at the second winery. The three wineries, in order of visit were: Sentinel Winery; Winette Vineyards and Dogwood Estate Winery. All three had full offerings of varietals and blends. At Sentinel and Dogwood we bought their reds and at Winette we bought some whites. The Daly Inn is a Victorian that is over one hundred years old, but is in excellent shape. The décor is very well done and is the handy work of Donna Gafford. Donna and Bob are very gracious hosts that are very helpful with explaining the local sights and offering their knowledge of local restaurants. They also own and operate the Iris Inn across the street. We were given a tour of that operation which is also beautifully decorated.

Wonderful hosts in a beautiful, beautiful home. The service & breakfasts were outstanding!

The rooms and communal spaces are clean and nicely appointed, all keeping in the period of the home. Very comfortable. Breakfast was tasty and well-presented.

I feel very comfortable at this B&B, the room was cozy and very well maintained. The breakfast was delicious. I am definitely coming back when I am going to be in the Eureka area. Thank you!

We were delighted with our stay in this wonderful inn. Great hospitality, and immaculate beautifully furnished inn. Wonderful breakfast.

Excellent service, food, hospitality -- really clean!

Comfortable rooms & excellent food! will definitely recommend to everyone. Great atmosphere. Will return.

Spacious and very comfortable place. Kind and accomodating host. Walking distance to historic downtown. Fantastic breakfast.

The inn is like stepping back in time to enjoy the luxury of an elegant era. Everything is first class, and the wine tour is the best I have ever seen. you must do it!

Bob and Donna have created a B&B experience that can't be matched in Humboldt country. And their new wine tour is fabulous! A must-do event!

A beautiful colonial revival B&B with outstanding and friendly service and modern rooms.

This B&B was a wonderful place to come to after a long drive. it felt like coming home, only better. Bob met our every need. The decor was charming, food excellent, and the room comfortable!

Enjoy a stay in an elegant B&B. the breakfast is unbelievable and the hosts are gracious. Redwoods and ocean views are outstanding and nearby!

The breakfasts are delicious and excellently prepared! The beds are soft and the rooms spacious! Great town, hiking and gorgeous ocean and fine restaurants too!

We walked in to the front door of the Cornelius Daly Inn and were welcomed by friendly staff. The inn is elegantly decorated right down to the smallest detail. Late afternoon wine and hors d'oeuvres are a real treat. The food is delicious and the service impeccable. We definitely recommend this B&B if you are looking for a special place to stay!

We live in the Willamette Valley of Oregon, about 6.5 hours by car from Eureka. Though we are happy with Oregon, we like to get away from time to time. The Cornelius Daly Inn, booked for a weekend in late January, 2009, turned out to be the right place for us. The website was attractive, but the main house, and the auxiliary house (a fine place in its own right) across the street, exceeded our expectations. Eureka is a good destination, with the redwoods, the rugged coastline and the finer tastes that Bay Area money can bring (quirky bookstores with unusual books, good restaurants), available in a leisurely and uncrowded setting. Our hosts, Donna and Bob, gave us attentive care without impinging on our romantic getaway - complete with a fine suite and fireplace. We would recommend the Cornelius Daly Inn to anyone who appreciates the timber-era understated elegance of the Pacific Northwest.